In his first 11 days as a candidate for national office, Sen. JD Vance has garnered significant attention, but not for positive reasons. The Ohio Republican has made a poor first impression, with many in his own party criticizing Donald Trump’s choice of him as a running mate. Vance became the first vice presidential candidate in modern history to have a negative favorability rating just a week after his party’s convention.
Central to the controversy surrounding Vance are remarks he made three years ago during his initial Senate campaign. On Fox News, he asserted that the United States was being run by “a bunch of childless cat ladies who are miserable at their own lives,” including Vice President Kamala Harris.
This statement has been widely condemned for its implication that those without biological children are lesser and unreliable as leaders.
The backlash to Vance’s rhetoric has been swift and intense, extending beyond the usual political discourse. His comments have been widely criticized for their inherent misogyny and baseless generalizations, drawing sharp rebukes from various quarters. The phrase “childless cat ladies” has become particularly notorious, as noted by CNN’s Andy Kaczynski, for encapsulating a negative view of Vance among many people.
In an attempt to address the uproar, Vance spoke with Megyn Kelly, describing his previous comments as sarcastic and claiming that the focus should be on the supposed anti-family stance of the left. However, his clarification did little to quell the controversy, as it seemed to misinterpret the core issue—whether he holds prejudiced views against women, not cats.
Vance’s efforts to mitigate the damage have largely backfired, as he failed to convincingly distance himself from his original comments. By doubling down on his stance without substantial evidence to back his claims about liberals being “anti-child,” Vance has only deepened the public’s unfavorable perception of him. His inability to effectively defend his statements suggests that this issue will continue to trouble his candidacy.