On June 17, 2024, an Indian migrant worker, Satnam Singh, tragically bled to death after his arm was severed by farm equipment in Latina, Italy. The farm owner, Antonello Lovato, is facing charges for murder, initially considered manslaughter, after abandoning the injured Singh without seeking medical help. Prosecutors upgraded the charge to murder with malice after the fact, as Lovato was aware that his actions, or lack thereof, could result in Singh’s death.
Lovato’s Emotional Instability Defense Contrasted with Union’s Push for Migrant Worker Justice
At the opening of his trial, Lovato expressed regret, stating he “lost his head” upon witnessing the gruesome scene of Singh’s injury. He claimed he was overwhelmed by panic and did not intend for the worker to die. Lovato’s defense suggests a moment of emotional instability, but prosecutors argue his failure to act exacerbated the situation, leading to Singh’s fatal outcome.

Italy’s largest trade union confederation, CGIL, has become an active participant in the legal proceedings, joining the prosecution as civil complainants. The union’s leadership, including Secretary-General Maurizio Landini, criticized the exploitation of migrant laborers in Italy’s agricultural sector. They pointed to a broader problem of poor working conditions and exploitation, particularly in the context of “caporalato” — a system of illegal labor recruitment where workers are treated as disposable commodities.
Landini Calls for Reform to End Exploitation and Injustice in Italy’s Agricultural Sector
Landini emphasized that the incident highlights a systemic issue in Italy’s agricultural industry, where migrant workers, often underpaid and overworked, are vulnerable to exploitation. He argued that the culture of treating workers as “parts of a machine” needs to change and that this tragedy is not an isolated case but part of a wider problem that affects many migrant laborers in the country.
As the trial progresses, with the next hearing scheduled for May 27, 2024, the CGIL continues to advocate for justice. They stress that this case should be seen as a catalyst for broader reforms within Italy’s agricultural sector. The union expresses concern that without systemic change, similar incidents of exploitation and injustice may continue, especially as the new harvest season approaches.